Project Log 001
The site that started Handbuilt.
A 65-year family plumbing shop was paying an agency $1,930 a month for a website that didn't bring in work. That shop is mine. Here's what I found when I finally looked at my own numbers, what I rebuilt, and what it saved.
Same business. Same 4.9-star reputation. One headline is interchangeable. The other is true.
The problem
I run Tom Falk Plumbing & Heating — the family shop Jim and Edna Falk started in 1961. I married into this family, so I didn't inherit the name so much as I earned my way into caring about it. For years we paid an agency $1,930 every month: $430 of it just for hosting, and $1,500 for SEO and Google Business management. The traffic reports looked busy, so I assumed it was working.
Then I actually read one. The best-performing page they'd built me was a blog post about yellow bathwater. It got clicks. It brought in zero jobs. I was paying almost two thousand dollars a month for motion, and mistaking it for work.
What I found
So I opened my own Google Search Console and looked at where the actual calls were coming from. It wasn't the blog. It wasn't blue-link SEO at all. My real leads came from the Google Map Pack, my Local Services Ads, and decades of reviews and word of mouth.
I was spending $1,500 a month to rank for articles no customer ever turned into a phone call. The whole strategy was aimed at winning a search I was never going to win — and didn't need to. The people who wanted me were already finding me. The website just had to not lose them.
What I built
I threw it out and rebuilt the whole thing around the moment that actually decides the job: when someone finds me in the map pack and clicks through to size me up in the ten seconds before they call.
Every photo is my own crew's real work — the old site had a stock photo of someone else's bathroom sitting on top of a furnace page. The copy is straight: repair versus replace, why a load calc matters, no "trusted experts" filler. Twenty-five service pages and twelve town pages, each written for the place it's actually about. Schema markup built so I'm the answer, not so I chase a ranking. And it's a fast static site that costs about twenty dollars a month to run instead of four hundred and thirty.
Every line of it was written and is managed stateside — by me, here. Nothing is built or handed off offshore, and there's no farm of subcontractors you'll never meet. When something needs fixing, you're talking to the person who built it.
The result
| Before — the agency | After — built by hand | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost per month | $1,930 | A fraction — mine to run |
| Just to host it | $430 / month | Included |
| The headline | "Trusted Experts in… Services" | "The family shop… since 1961." |
| Photos | Stock (a bathroom on a furnace page) | Every one my real crew |
| Built to win | Blog traffic that never called | The map-pack trust moment |
| Speed (mobile) | Slow, bloated | 98 / 100 / 96, zero layout shift |
Tracked results — measuring now
Here's the one I won't fake. The real test isn't the money I stopped burning — it's calls. The rebuild goes live on the real domain before the old agency's SEO contract ends, and I'm tracking calls and form submissions from day one — the number the agency never bothered to measure. The honest before/after lands right here once the data is real. No invented "calls went up X%."
The old site was built to win a search I was never going to win. The new one's built to earn the call I was already getting. — Trevor, Tom Falk Plumbing & Heating
The honest part
Two things I'd want to know if I were on the other side of this. First: you own every line of code the day the site ships. It's yours — not licensed, not rented, not held on a platform you can't leave.
Second, the part most people won't say out loud: a site has to be hosted somewhere to stay online. While I host it, it's $49 a month and I keep it live, patched, and fast. If you ever stop — cancel with me and don't move it anywhere else — the site goes dark, the same as any website whose hosting lapses. But nothing is held hostage. You leave with the whole thing: every file, every photo, every line, ready to hand to any host you like. I'd rather tell you that plainly now than have it be a surprise later.
This one was my own company — which is exactly why I know it works, and it's the reason Handbuilt exists. If your website is built to chase traffic instead of earn the call, that's the thing I fix. Real photos, honest words, fast pages, a site pointed at the way your customers actually find you — and every line of it yours to keep.
Start a build